Sugar Cookie Taste Test

I owed a friend of mine a big thank-you for a favor he'd done, and I asked what he would like for me to bake for him as a gift. He said he wanted some of my mother's sugar cookies. My mom's sugar cookies are delicious, but since I had just made a large batch for Christmas and still had some in the freezer, I thought I would make this batch more interesting by turning it into a taste test.

The basic recipe calls for vanilla extract and orange peel as the key ingredients. I decided to make three different bathes of the base recipe:

1. vanilla extract + orange peel
2. orange extract + orange peel
3. lemon extract + lemon peel

Again, I am a fan of mis en place preparation -- lay everything out on the counter so that you know you have all your ingredients, and, so that they are ready to go when you need them. Plus, it makes clean-up a snap.

When doing a taste test like this, it's also important to keep your samples labeled. You don't know if they actually will taste any different in the end, so, you need to keep the organized until you know the verdict.

Here, the dough is wrapped in saran wrap, ready to go into the fridge for one hour.

Of course, the down side of doing a taste test like this is that you have an army of cookies after the fact that you have to ice and store. Rather than mess with that, I took them around to neighbors, brought them into the office, and presented several to my friend who had requested them in the first place.

Comments

Holly Tompkins said…

What was the verdict? Which was your favorite?

February 23, 2010 at 1:48 PM

Chicken Traybake with Roasted Poblano and Tomato Salsa

This dish is delicious! Easy! And, beautiful to look at! The original recipe calls for you to process all the cooked vegetables together into a chunky salsa, but I recommend serving it as is so you have an automatic side dish. The original also calls for cooking chicken bone-in, but, the more I cook traybakes, the more I advocate for slicing chicken into tenders and cooking boneless. Just a safer bake that way because everything comes to the same temperature at the same time. Chicken Traybake with Roasted Poblano and Tomato Salsa Milk Street 1 T chili powder 2 poblano, stemmed, seeded, chopped 1 yellow onion, root end intact, in 8 wedges 1 pint cherry tomatoes 1/4 c olive oil 1 T brown sugar 1 T oregano, dried 3 lb chicken, bone-in, skin-on, trimmed 10 cloves garlic, peeled 1 T vinegar 1/4 c cilantro, chopped Heat oven to 450. In small bowl, stir together chili powder and 2 tsp salt. In large bowl, toss together pobloanos, onion wedges, tomatoes, and 1 T of the chili-power...

Mayocoba Beans with Green Chiles

I love this dish so much that I can barely stand it. Delicious the night it was made, and fantastic as leftovers throughout the week. Mayocoba beans are easily replaced -- try pintos, if you can't find mayocobas. Mayocoba Beans with Green Chiles Baptism of Fire 3-4 green chiles, roasted and chopped 1 onion, chopped 1 clove garlic, minced 1 T lard or olive oil 1/2 tsp oregano 1 tsp cumin pepper 1 c mayocoba beans, dry 3 c water 1 tsp salt Cook the green chiles, onion, garlic, oregano, cumin, and black pepper in the fat until the onions begin to caramelize. Add the water and bring to a boil. Turn off the heat and let the beans sit, uncovered, for an hour. You may drain the water to remove some of the slightly indigestible sugars that cause gassiness. If you decide to drain them, add enough water back into the pot to cover the beans with about 2" of water above the beans for cooking. Bring the beans back to a boil and cook, until tender. This will take...

Curried Chicken Soup

I made this soup so often in the 1990s, but frankly had forgotten about it. Flipping through this cookbook, I found this recipe and was flooded with memories. When I was in grad school, this soup was my "feeling decadent" food and reminded me of something people might eat after hitting the slopes -- a thing I have never done. A few decades long, and with a lot more experience with cooking, I realize that this is basically a chicken curry with a thin sauce and the rice already in the meal -- but don't let that in any way discourage you! It's delicious as is and is a wonderful take on what is otherwise chicken and rice soup. I have become a fan of using rotisserie chickens, especially during the pandemic. They are so cheap, and I can use the meat in a soup like this on the day-of grocery shopping, and, crunch the bones down for the freezer for making stock in the future. Of course, this soup can be made with a fresh chicken, but I have modified the recipe bel...

Donut Army

Search This Blog